Blog
Thoughts on Beethoven
Posted: 12.18.2007
I was in Vienna after the Fitelberg competition. I went to the Zentralfriedhoff while there. (That is an incredible place, by the way - only comparable to Père-Lachaise). It's amazing to see who all is buried there: Beethoven, Schubert, Strauss (Johann Sr. AND Jr.), Brahms, and Schoenberg. It's pretty incredible. (I'll put pictures up soon - once I figure out how to download them off my camera).
I thought a lot about performing Beethoven when I was in Vienna. (It was partly prompted by the fact that the German judge, Andreas Weiss paid me the most incredible compliment I have received in a while - he asked for my video of Beethoven's Egmont to use in teaching his class because he thought I found the right spirit and story in my performance.)
I thought about it quite a lot while walking through Vienna. I had been thinking for a while about Beethoven since I had heard a terrible performance of Beethoven a while back. The problem was that it was well done from the technical perspective. The articulation, the intonation, the dynamics, etc. were great. The performance overall wasn't. I was debating it while I was in Vienna. (Where better to think about Beethoven?)
I think I figured out why I feel so attached to Beethoven - almost every one of his pieces triumphs over struggle. There was definitely his struggle with deafness, which created many other struggles such as his isolation from people. I think that this understanding of struggle and overcoming that struggle and seeing the presence of hope at all times that makes his music work. (This is all opinion and conjecture - in other words, it's my view of the man through the music as opposed the music through the man, which is one thing that I really try to piece out).
I think that you have to keep in mind that he never lost hope. He never gave up. (Jimmy V would be proud).